1. Board of Directors Meetings
The Board holds regular monthly meetings and special board meetings to deliberate on major issues affecting the Company. Ordinarily, the Board adopts a formal and sequential agenda for each regular meeting. The agenda include brief reports or updates by the Chairman and the Board Committees, reports on financial performance by the Chief Finance Officer, and operational performance by the President and Chief Operating Officer. The agenda also include items for the Board’s deliberation and approval.
In 2009, the Board held twelve (12) regular meetings and one (1) special meeting. The details of attendance of each director in these meetings and their corresponding number of meetings as of their appointment are recorded below.
| Member | Designation | Attendance |
| Manuel M. Lopez | Chairman and CEO | 13/13 |
| Ramon S. Ang | Vice-Chairman and Director | 11/13 |
| Ray C. Espinosa | Director | 13/13 |
| Artemio V. Panganiban | Director (Independent Director) | 13/13 |
| Jose P. de Jesus | Director | 13/13 |
| Vicente L. Panlilio | Director (Independent Director) | 12/13 |
| Estelito P. Mendoza | Director | 10/13 |
| Manuel V. Pangilinan | Director | 7/7 |
| Napoleon L. Nazareno | Director | 7/7 |
| Elpi O. Cuna | Director | 2/2 |
| Elenita D. Go | Director | 2/2 |
| Aurora T. Calderon | Past Director | 6/6 |
| Eduardo M. Cojuangco Jr. | Past Director | 2/6 |
| Jesus P. Francisco | Past Director | 6/6 |
| Christian S. Monsod | Past Director | 5/6 |
| Alan T. Ortiz | Past Director | 4/5 |
| Mario K. Surio | Past Director | 5/5 |
| Cesar E.A. Virata | Past Director | 6/6 |
The average attendance rate in 2009 was 92% and average duration of meetings was 1.80 hours.
Also shown below are the participations of the directors on the Annual Stockholders and Organizational meetings, both conducted last May 26, 2009:
| Member | Designation | Annual SH Meeting | Organizational Meeting |
| Manuel M. Lopez | Chairman and CEO | Present | Present |
| Ramon S. Ang1 | Vice-Chairman | Present | Present |
| Ray C. Espinosa7 | Director | - | Present |
| Artemio V. Panganiban | Director (Independent) | Present | Present |
| Jose P. de Jesus1 | Director | Present | Present |
| Vicente L. Panlilio5 | Director (Independent) | Present | Present |
| Estelito P. Mendoza1 | Director | Present | Present |
| Manuel V. Pangilinan2 | Director | - | Present |
| Napoleon L. Nazareno2 | Director | - | Present |
| Elpi O. Cuna3 | Director | - | - |
| Elenita D. Go3 | Director | - | - |
| Aurora T. Calderon1 | Past Director | Present | - |
| Eduardo M. Cojuangco Jr.1 | Past Director | Absent | - |
| Mario K. Surio2 | Past Director | - | Present |
| Ian T. Ortiz2 | Past Director | - | Present |
| Jesus P. Francisco | Past Director | Present | - |
| Christian S. Monsod4 | Past Director | Present | - |
| Cesar E.A. Virata6, 7 | Past Director | Present | - |
2 Elected during the May 26, 2009 Annual SH Meeting
3 Elected on November 23, 2009 vice Messrs. Alan T. Ortiz and Mario K. Surio who resigned in November 2009
4 Chairman, Nomination and Governance Committee
5 Chairman, Audit and Compliance Committee
6 Chairman, Compensation and Requirement Committee
7 Chairman, Finance Committee
2. Board Committees
-
Nomination and Governance
The Nomination and Governance Committee is composed of at least three (3) directors, one of whom must be independent. This committee is responsible for screening qualified nominees for election as directors; assessing the independence of directors; introducing improvements on board organization and procedures; setting-up of mechanisms for performance evaluation of the Board and Management; and, providing programs for continuing education of the Board, including training for individual directors.
In 2009, the Nomination and Governance Committee held a total of eight (8) meetings. Among the activities undertaken by the committee are the following: review and selection of the nominees for election as members of the Board; review of rules on nomination of candidates, validation of proxies, and appreciation of ballots; review of board committee charters and reorganization of board committees; propose amendment to the Company’s By-Laws; and review of revisions to the Manual of Corporate Governance.
Attendance of the committee members, and their corresponding number of meetings as of their appointment, is shown below:
Member Designation Attendance Artemio V. Panganiban Chairman (Independent Director) 7/7 Estelito P. Mendoza Member 6/7 Napoleon L. Nazareno Member 3/5 Elpidio L. Ibanez Non-Director 3/5 Vicente L. Panlilio* Past Member 1/1 Christian S. Monsod Past Member 3/3 Felipe B. Alfonso Past Member 1/1
-
Audit and Risk Management
The Audit and Risk Management Committee is composed of at five (5) directors who possess accounting and financial backgrounds, two (2) of whom shall be an independent directors, and another with understanding of auditing concepts and basic auditing processes, or related audit experience or professional accreditation as an auditor.
The committee held a total of seven (7) meetings in 2009. Among the matters taken-up by the committee are the following: review of the Company's 2008 audited financial statements and 2009 quarterly financial statements; financial performance of subsidiaries and affiliates; actuarial valuation of the Company's pension fund; review and approval of the 2008 Audit Committee report; nomination of the external auditor for 2009; review and approval of the 2009 internal audit plan, budget, and covenants; review of 2008 internal audit performance and report; review of external auditor's 2009 financial statement audit plan and audit fees; evaluation of the Company's risk profile and management structure, systems and processes, and approval of the risk management policy manual; review of the 2008 audited financial statements of the pension fund; and revisions to this committee's charter.
Attendance of the committee members, and their corresponding number of meetings as of their appointment, is shown below:
Member Designation Attendance Vicente L. Panlilio Chairman (Independent Director) 7/7 Napoleon L. Nazareno Member 4/4 Alan T. Ortiz Member 4/4 Aurora T. Calderon Non-Director 5/7 Elpidio L. Ibanez Non-Director 4/4 Jose P. de Jesus Past Member 3/3 Estelito P. Mendoza Past Member 0/3 Artemio V. Panganiban Past Member 3/3
-
Compensation and Benefits
The Compensation and Benefits Committee is composed of at least three (3) directors, one of whom shall be an independent director.
The Committee held a total of six (6) meetings in 2009. Discussions and deliberations pertained to the Company's total compensation policy, philosophy and design, 2008 incentive program, 2008 performance evaluation results, and proposals for the 2009 performance management system and plans; performance evaluation of the Chairman and CEO; the Company's balanced scorecard results; promotion policy for officers; nomination and appointments to the pension fund board of trustees; actuarial studies on the pension fund and retirement plan; retirement policy and retirement pay options; granting of committee meeting fees for non-directors; and revision to this committee's charter and change in committee name.
Attendance of the committee members, and their corresponding number of meetings as of their appointment, is shown below:
Member Designation Attendance Napoleon L. Nazareno Chairman 3/3 Manuel M. Lopez Member 3/3 Alan T. Ortiz Member 3/3 Vicente L. Panlilio Member (Independent Director) 3/3 Cezar E. A. Virata Past Director 3/3 Aurora T. Calderon Past Member 3/3 Christian S. Monsod Past Member 2/3
-
3. Finance
The Finance Committee is composed of at least three (3) directors, with the Company's Chief Finance Officer as ex-officio member.
This committee held a total of twelve (12) meetings in 2009. Among the matters acted upon by the committee were: the approval of the corporate budget; review and approval of the medium-term financial plans; approval of cash dividend declaration for common and preferred shares; review of financial performance of subsidiaries and investment returns; review of quarterly cash projections and finance operations report; review of disbursement approval process; redemption on preferred shares; evaluation of debt refinancing; contribution to the pension fund; divestment of shareholdings in affiliate company; review of major purchases and contracts; and approval of bank accreditation and signing authorities.
Attendance of the committee members, and their corresponding number of meetings as of their appointment, is shown below:
Member Designation Attendance Ray C. Espinosa Chairman 6/6 Jose P. de Jesus Member 6/6 Alan T. Ortiz Member 4/5 Anabelle L. Chua Non-Director 4/6 Ferdinand K. Constantino Non-Director 10/11 Ramon S. Ang Past Member 5/5 Estellito P. Mendoza Past Member 5/5 Artemio V. Panganiban Past Member (Independent Director) 5/5 Cesar E.A. Virata Past Director 5/5 Daisy P. Arce Past Director 1/1 Jesus P. Francisco Past Director 5/5 Christian S. Monsod Past Director 1/1
4. Other Meetings/Seminars
-
Corporate Governance Seminar of the Board of Directors
The Board of Directors assesses the trainings they require for the purpose of continuing their education in corporate governance and then attend such trainings.
Board of Director Name of Institutional
Training Provider &
AddressDate of
CompletionCertifier Manuel M. Lopez Knowledge Institute
6760 Ayala Avenue, Makati CityJul. 11, 2003 Cecile R. Galvez, Partner Ramon S. Ang University of the Philipines
Law Center and San Miguel CorporationSep. 25, 2003 Danillo L. Concepcion, Associate Dean and Supervisor (U.P. Law Center) Estelito P. Mendoza University of the Philipines
Law Center and San Miguel CorporationSep. 25, 2003 Danillo L. Concepcion, Associate Dean and Supervisor (U.P. Law Center) Manuel V. Pangilinan Corporate Governance Trends in Asia Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company Ramon Cojuangco Bldg., Makati Ave, Makati City May 8, 2007 Chee Keong Low, Professor - Chinese University of Hong Kong, Member - Listing Committee, Hong Kong Stock Exchange Current Governance Environment in the United States and Ethics and Tone at the Top
First Pacific Company Limited, 2 Exchange Square, Connaught Road, Central Hong KongDecember 12, 2008 Suzanne Hopgood, Director - Board Advisory Services National Association of Corporate Directors, Washington DC, USA Governing in a Global Crisis Lessons from the Great RecessionPLDT’s CG Education Program with Ethics and Compliance Officer Association (ECOA), 11 Waverley Oaks Road, Suite 324, Waltham, Massachusetts, 02452 USA
Resource Person: Keith T. Darcy - Executive Director, Ethics and Compliance Officer Association (ECOA) held at the East and West Rooms, Mandarin Oriental Hotel, Connaught Road, Central Hong KongDecember 10, 2009 Keith T. Darcy - Executive Director, Ethics and Compliance Officer Association (ECOA) Atty. Ray C. Espinosa Corporate Governance Trends in Asia Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company Ramon Cojuangco Bldg., Makati Ave, Makati City May 8, 2007 Chee Keong Low, Professor - Chinese University of Hong Kong, Member - Listing Committee, Hong Kong Stock Exchange Current Governance Environment in the United States and Ethics and Tone at the Top
First Pacific Company Limited, 2 Exchange Square, Connaught Road, Central Hong KongDec. 12, 2008 Suzanne Hopgood, Director - Board Advisory Services National Association of Corporate Directors, Washington DC, USA Governing in a Global Crisis Lessons from the Great RecessionPLDT’s CG Education Program with Ethics and Compliance Officer Association (ECOA), 11 Waverley Oaks Road, Suite 324, Waltham, Massachusetts, 02452 USA
Resource Person: Keith T. Darcy - Executive Director, Ethics and Compliance Officer Association (ECOA) held at the East and West Rooms, Mandarin Oriental Hotel, Connaught Road, Central Hong KongDecember 10, 2009 Keith T. Darcy - Executive Director, Ethics and Compliance Officer Association (ECOA) Napoleon L. Nazareno Corporate Governance Trends in Asia Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company Ramon Cojuangco Bldg., Makati Ave, Makati City May 8, 2007 Chee Keong Low, Professor - Chinese University of Hong Kong, Member - Listing Committee, Hong Kong Stock Exchange Ethical Leadership Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company, Manila Peninsula hotel, Makati City Oct. 10, 2007 Dr. Antonete Palma-Angeles, Director, JB Fernandez, Center for Ethics, Ateneo de Manila University The Global Financial Crisis and Corporate Governance and Stages of Corporate Moral Development Makati Shangri-la Plaza, Makati City Oct. 28, 2008 Dr. Jesus P. Estanislao, Chairman Institute of Corporate Directors and Dr. Antonette Palma-Angeles, Director, JB Fernandez, Center for Ethics, Ateneo de Manila University Current Governance Environment in the United States and Ethics and Tone at the Top
First Pacific Company Limited, 2 Exchange Square, Connaught Road, Central Hong KongDec. 12, 2008 Suzanne Hopgood, Director - Board Advisory Services National Association of Corporate Directors, Washington DC, USA Governing in a Global Crisis Lessons from the Great RecessionPLDT’s CG Education Program with Ethics and Compliance Officer Association (ECOA), 11 Waverley Oaks Road, Suite 324, Waltham, Massachusetts, 02452 USA
Resource Person: Keith T. Darcy - Executive Director, Ethics and Compliance Officer Association (ECOA) held at the East and West Rooms, Mandarin Oriental Hotel, Connaught Road, Central Hong KongDecember 10, 2009 Keith T. Darcy - Executive Director, Ethics and Compliance Officer Association (ECOA) Oscar S. Reyes The Institute of Corporate Directors in cooperation with the Insurance Institute for Asia and the Pacific, Makati City Nov. 10, 2005 Jesus P Estanislao, Chairman, ICD and Melecio C. Mallillin, President, IIAP Development Finance Institute, Makati City Sep. 23-24, 2002 Antonio R. Narciso, Executive Director Ret. Chief Justice Artemio V. Panganiban Basic Course on Corporate GovernanceAsian Institute of Management (AIM) Amb. Ramon V. del Rosario, Sr. - Corporate Citizenship Initiative, Makati City Jun. 17, 2008 Angela G. Garcia, Executive Director, Ramon V. del Rosario, Sr. - C.V. Starr Center for Corporate Governance Francis G. Estrada, President, Asian Institute of Management Governing in a Global Crisis Lessons from the Great RecessionPLDT’s CG Education Program with Ethics and Compliance Officer Association (ECOA), 11 Waverley Oaks Road, Suite 324, Waltham, Massachusetts, 02452 USA
Resource Person: Keith T. Darcy - Executive Director, Ethics and Compliance Officer Association (ECOA) held at the East and West Rooms, Mandarin Oriental Hotel, Connaught Road, Central Hong KongDecember 10, 2009 Keith T. Darcy - Executive Director, Ethics and Compliance Officer Association (ECOA) Vicente L. Panlilio Institute of Corporte Directors, Makati City Sep. 27-28, 2002 Jesus P. Estanislao, President and CEO Eric O. Recto Manabat Sanagustin & Co., Certified Public Accountants, Enterprise Tower, Makati City Feb. 27, 2008 Roberto G. Manabat, Chairman and CEO Pedro Emilio E. Roxas Corporate Governance Trends in Asia Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company Ramon Cojuangco Bldg., Makati Ave., Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines May 8, 2007 Chee Keong Low, Professor - Chinese University of Hong Kong, Member - Listing Committee, Hong Kong Stock Exchange Current Governance Environment in the United States and Ethics and Tone at the Top
First Pacific Company Limited, 2 Exchange Square, Connaught Road, Central Hong KongDec. 12, 2008 Suzanne Hopgood, Director - Board Advisory Services National Association of Corporate Directors, Washington DC, USA Governing in a Global Crisis Lessons from the Great RecessionPLDT’s CG Education Program with Ethics and Compliance Officer Association (ECOA), 11 Waverley Oaks Road, Suite 324, Waltham, Massachusetts, 02452 USA
Resource Person: Keith T. Darcy - Executive Director, Ethics and Compliance Officer Association (ECOA) held at the East and West Rooms, Mandarin Oriental Hotel, Connaught Road, Central Hong KongDecember 10, 2009 Keith T. Darcy - Executive Director, Ethics and Compliance Officer Association (ECOA)



